Sunday, March 7, 2010
Reading Reflection 5 - Jacque Teague: Change Agent
What efforts will I make to change public education? I suppose that remains to be seen. I’m sure that my understanding of how I can make a difference and what ways I will want to make a difference will change over the course of my career. My environment and experiences will likely impact these decisions as well. However, I am certain that I will respond in progressively larger ways to feelings of discontent or discomfort I experience in reaction to the way I am or am expected to teach my students. I responded positively to the inquiry method of teaching math in the Postman and Weingarnter chapter. I know that I will attempt to incorporate activities and experiences for my students that try to engage them in constructing meaning for themselves rather than being fed it. The more I observe different math teachers, the more I realize that this is not often done in math classes. While I certainly respect the skill that veteran math teachers bring to explaining complex concepts to students clearly and providing them with guided practice in applying these concepts in a very appropriate sequence, I do not often notice an inquiry approach being used. I suppose that in this way, I will be implementing change in my classroom, no matter how small the scale of that change. As suggested in the Fullen and Hargreaves chapter, I will also enact small changes by seeking opportunities to collaborate with colleagues and receive feedback from them. I will also strive to create variety in my classroom and not become stagnate in my implementation of lessons. I will try to add to my variety of approaches by reading professional journals for ideas and by taking risks on ideas I have, even though they may not work well the first time around. Most importantly, I will not ignore my inner voice, as Fullen and Hargreaves put it. Even when I want to ignore it, my personality will not allow it. I take pride in knowing that I am doing my job well and I am too reflective of a person. I know that I will not be able to blame lack of meaningful learning on state standards or unmotivated students or lack of time. I have to admit that I sometimes wish I could. Instead I am more likely to put pressure on myself to be more creative in my instructional approaches. I am not a loud voice, but I am a consistent soft one that is more comfortable making changes in small steps, in my own classroom and through my collaboration with a couple of colleagues. Maybe as I gain more experience and clout at my school, I will be a soft voice that others begin to listen to and I will be able to make bigger changes that impact more students.
Saturday, February 27, 2010
Reading Reflection 5 - I'm thinking...
I feel that one of my major focuses this semester has been on cooperative learning. I have been thinking a lot about the necessary student training and teacher planning that goes along with it to increase success. I’ve also been reflecting on my Clinical Practice 1 experiences, and observations I’ve made of classrooms this semester that are engaging in group work. The distinction has become clear to me between group work and cooperative learning. I feel excited about but also intimidated with trying to facilitate successful cooperative learning in my classrooms. I believe the skills necessary for students to engage in effective cooperative learning are some of the most important skills they can learn in preparing for the future.
As I read Cohen’s chapter about assigning group members roles and I think about the cooperative learning games that we’ve played in our EDSS 541 class, I wonder how much of an effect each of these things really has on cooperative learning. I wonder whether using these strategies will really teach high school students new skills that will help them work better in groups and improve their communication skills. I hope so. I am willing to try. Ensuring that students are performing their group roles seems like yet another layer to attend to as I thoughtfully facilitate my lessons. It feels like there are so many layers to attend to already! I suppose that is why a teacher never gets bored. There’s always something new to learn from or improve or focus on.
As I read Cohen’s chapter about assigning group members roles and I think about the cooperative learning games that we’ve played in our EDSS 541 class, I wonder how much of an effect each of these things really has on cooperative learning. I wonder whether using these strategies will really teach high school students new skills that will help them work better in groups and improve their communication skills. I hope so. I am willing to try. Ensuring that students are performing their group roles seems like yet another layer to attend to as I thoughtfully facilitate my lessons. It feels like there are so many layers to attend to already! I suppose that is why a teacher never gets bored. There’s always something new to learn from or improve or focus on.
CP2 Website
I have just begun to work on my website. The basic skeleton is up and now I just need to fill in content. You can view it at: https://sites.google.com/site/teaguemath/
Sunday, February 21, 2010
Reading Reflection 4 - Groupwork ch. 4-5
Each section of these two chapters on groupwork caught my attention since I have become very interested in making cooperative learning happen effectively in my future classrooms and in avoiding some of the pitfalls I have experienced in clinical practice when students work in groups. I will focus my reading reflection on planning evaluation, though, because evaluation is of great interest to my students and I know that I will need to have my answers down pat on this regard because my students and possibly their parents will likely have questions.
The way that evaluation is carried out influences groupwork. Cohen cautions that teachers must be careful to not evaluate student understanding too early in the group process. Individual students may not master the learning objectives after one group activity. Their light bulb may go off after the second or third, but if a teacher becomes too eager in ensuring that students are understanding every concept and getting all of the right answers, they will take away from the benefits of the group process and the critical thinking of individual students. This will be a challenge for me in teaching math. I have grown so accustomed to good teachers being those who have the littlest confusion going on in their classrooms. But as Cohen suggests, confusion is not necessarily bad and can lead students to deeper understandings as they explore concepts more deeply and learn from one another.
Cohen also suggests that teachers should provide specific feedback on group process performance as well as the actual content the group produces. If a teacher wants to evaluate individual student learning, Cohen states that they might give a test after the groupwork process is finished, to ascertain what each group member learned. If group grades are given, Cohen warns that some group members may be excluded from contributing because they are viewed as having weaker skills. Further, grading individual group members on their contributions to the group project may not be fair, since some individuals may have been excluded from contributing. If students are to give constructive feedback to one another on their groupwork, they must be trained in socially acceptable and sensitive ways to do so.
Cohen advises educators that they should think before they create competitive groupwork environments, or groupwork that is focused on earning an external reward as motivation. She asserts that rich tasks can result in the same level of motivation and feedback and positive reinforcement can be provided instead of grades.
I will definitely use groupwork in my own classroom and will be challenged to come up with tasks and strategies that motivate and train students to work well in groups. I will have to devise ways of evaluating student learning and assigning grades fairly. In teaching math, there are so many ways that cooperative learning can contribute to individual student learning through rich problem solving experiences. Every student is a critical thinker and can contribute when tasks are designed correctly. I think that I will likely use cooperative learning tasks as a means for students to learn about concepts in a meaningful way as well as learn to work in groups effectively. I will likely utilize individual tests and reports to evaluate whether each student has met the learning objectives at hand.
The way that evaluation is carried out influences groupwork. Cohen cautions that teachers must be careful to not evaluate student understanding too early in the group process. Individual students may not master the learning objectives after one group activity. Their light bulb may go off after the second or third, but if a teacher becomes too eager in ensuring that students are understanding every concept and getting all of the right answers, they will take away from the benefits of the group process and the critical thinking of individual students. This will be a challenge for me in teaching math. I have grown so accustomed to good teachers being those who have the littlest confusion going on in their classrooms. But as Cohen suggests, confusion is not necessarily bad and can lead students to deeper understandings as they explore concepts more deeply and learn from one another.
Cohen also suggests that teachers should provide specific feedback on group process performance as well as the actual content the group produces. If a teacher wants to evaluate individual student learning, Cohen states that they might give a test after the groupwork process is finished, to ascertain what each group member learned. If group grades are given, Cohen warns that some group members may be excluded from contributing because they are viewed as having weaker skills. Further, grading individual group members on their contributions to the group project may not be fair, since some individuals may have been excluded from contributing. If students are to give constructive feedback to one another on their groupwork, they must be trained in socially acceptable and sensitive ways to do so.
Cohen advises educators that they should think before they create competitive groupwork environments, or groupwork that is focused on earning an external reward as motivation. She asserts that rich tasks can result in the same level of motivation and feedback and positive reinforcement can be provided instead of grades.
I will definitely use groupwork in my own classroom and will be challenged to come up with tasks and strategies that motivate and train students to work well in groups. I will have to devise ways of evaluating student learning and assigning grades fairly. In teaching math, there are so many ways that cooperative learning can contribute to individual student learning through rich problem solving experiences. Every student is a critical thinker and can contribute when tasks are designed correctly. I think that I will likely use cooperative learning tasks as a means for students to learn about concepts in a meaningful way as well as learn to work in groups effectively. I will likely utilize individual tests and reports to evaluate whether each student has met the learning objectives at hand.
Saturday, February 13, 2010
Reading Reflection 3 - Groupwork Ch. 1-3
Elizabeth Cohen’s first chapter of Designing Groupwork is titled “Groupwork as a Strategy for Classrooms.” She emphasizes that groupwork is not ability grouping for easier homogeneous instruction, but rather “students working together in a group small enough so that everyone can participate on a task that has been clearly assigned.” Cohen states that a couple of the key characteristics of groupwork are the delegated authority it affords students with and students needing their groupmates to be successful in completing a task. Students need to be prepared adequately in order for groupwork to be worthwhile.
I found it hard to completely delegate authority to student groups during my clinical practice experience. I noticed myself hovering and hoping to correct or guide students around mistakes or pitfalls. I think that a few different things contributed to my difficulties: pacing guide time constraints, discomfort with student confusion, and lack of student preparation (on my part) for effective groupwork. I am eager to improve my groupwork designs and strategies in the classroom and truly do believe that the best way for students to learn is to make discoveries for themselves. I believe that they will make these discoveries if I am patient enough to allow them to do so.
Cohen’s second chapter titled “Why Groupwork?” gives a number of research supported reasons that groupwork is an effective strategy for improving student learning in a variety of areas. She provides evidence for groupwork improving student problem solving skills, higher order thinking skills, oral language proficiency, relationships with classmates, preparation for adult roles and decision making, time on-task, and basic skills. Cohen points out that students must be prepared for how to engage effectively in groupwork tasks, and that tasks must be conceptual in nature, rather than requiring memorization or application of a specific rule.
Reflecting back on my clinical practice experiences last semester, I feel lucky to have had the chance to work within a math department that valued cooperative learning so much. The Algebra 1 teachers almost always designed lessons where students had a chance to work on conceptual tasks in groups, and groups were always heterogeneously composed. Department meetings focused on learning goals that were outside of content standards in addition to the content standards themselves and many of these learning objectives were those that can be accomplished by students through cooperative learning experiences.
Cohen’s third chapter titled “The Dilemma of Groupwork” she describes the various status structures that evolve during groupwork. Students are ranked according to their perceived ability, which is often determined from one characteristic such as reading ability, societal status, and social status. Students with higher ranks in groups talk more, are relied upon more heavily, and are more engaged in the group task. This is problematic because students of lower status levels do not have the same access to learning opportunities.
I definitely encountered these problems during my clinical practice work last semester. As I monitored groupwork, I noticed that some students dominated the conversations, some students were ignored, and some students disengaged completely.
The next thing that I am looking forward to learning about in future chapters of this book is suggestions on how to engage all students in groupwork and eliminate some of the status problems t hat arise. I am interested in finding out more about how to prepare students for effective groupwork and how to prepare optimal tasks for groupwork.
I found it hard to completely delegate authority to student groups during my clinical practice experience. I noticed myself hovering and hoping to correct or guide students around mistakes or pitfalls. I think that a few different things contributed to my difficulties: pacing guide time constraints, discomfort with student confusion, and lack of student preparation (on my part) for effective groupwork. I am eager to improve my groupwork designs and strategies in the classroom and truly do believe that the best way for students to learn is to make discoveries for themselves. I believe that they will make these discoveries if I am patient enough to allow them to do so.
Cohen’s second chapter titled “Why Groupwork?” gives a number of research supported reasons that groupwork is an effective strategy for improving student learning in a variety of areas. She provides evidence for groupwork improving student problem solving skills, higher order thinking skills, oral language proficiency, relationships with classmates, preparation for adult roles and decision making, time on-task, and basic skills. Cohen points out that students must be prepared for how to engage effectively in groupwork tasks, and that tasks must be conceptual in nature, rather than requiring memorization or application of a specific rule.
Reflecting back on my clinical practice experiences last semester, I feel lucky to have had the chance to work within a math department that valued cooperative learning so much. The Algebra 1 teachers almost always designed lessons where students had a chance to work on conceptual tasks in groups, and groups were always heterogeneously composed. Department meetings focused on learning goals that were outside of content standards in addition to the content standards themselves and many of these learning objectives were those that can be accomplished by students through cooperative learning experiences.
Cohen’s third chapter titled “The Dilemma of Groupwork” she describes the various status structures that evolve during groupwork. Students are ranked according to their perceived ability, which is often determined from one characteristic such as reading ability, societal status, and social status. Students with higher ranks in groups talk more, are relied upon more heavily, and are more engaged in the group task. This is problematic because students of lower status levels do not have the same access to learning opportunities.
I definitely encountered these problems during my clinical practice work last semester. As I monitored groupwork, I noticed that some students dominated the conversations, some students were ignored, and some students disengaged completely.
The next thing that I am looking forward to learning about in future chapters of this book is suggestions on how to engage all students in groupwork and eliminate some of the status problems t hat arise. I am interested in finding out more about how to prepare students for effective groupwork and how to prepare optimal tasks for groupwork.
Monday, February 8, 2010
School Reform at Lunch
http://www.essentialschools.org/pub/ces_docs/ssp/conversion/list.html Tyhee High School and Olympic High School have been converted (restructured) from large schools to academies to make their schools "feel" and operate smaller. Olympic created academies that are interest based.
Sunday, February 7, 2010
Reading Reflection 2
As I think about BPHS's practices, there are a few that stand out to me and seem to me to likely be more salient in the student learning successes they have had. These three practices are aligned with some of the 6 Components for Comprehensive Reform posed by the CA Department of Education in the 1992 vision for a new California high school in the document Second to None:
1. Creating Curricular Paths to Success;
2. Developing Powerful Teaching and Learning;
3. Establishing a Comprehensive Accountability and Assessment System;
4. Providing Comprehensive Support for All Students;
5. Restructuring the School; and
6. Creating New Professional Roles.
First, I think that the internships and career experience they provide students with sets them apart from other schools. Students are able to see direct connections for what they are learning and working on and their futures. They are able to build connections with comminity members, gain work experience, and engage in activities that are meaningful to them. They have a voice in what internships they apply to and hopefully are more engaged as a result. This practice appears to be aligned with creating curricular paths to sucess, restructuring the school and developing powerful teaching and learning.
I also think that the integrated units that BPHS implements are key to their success in helping students experience a more connected and meaningful learning experience at school. Without teachers who collaborate to make their instruction/activities stretch across content areas, studetns would continue to have a fragmented and disjointed educational experience. This practice certainly exemplifies powerful teaching and learning, creates curricular paths to success, and creates new professional roles.
Lastly, I think that their "small school feel" allows them to manage student learning experiences more effectively, making ITU's, internships, and collaboration more feasible. In order for schools who are not small like BPHS to create a small school feel, they must restructure the school and provide comprehensive support for all students so that each individual feels a sense of belonging and purpose.
At my Clinical Practice 1 site, San Dieguito Academy, they used a unique schedule to foster student choice and facilitate project-based learning. The 4x4 schedule that they used allowed students to focus deeply on four subjects at a time for a semster, and then choose four other subjects of focus for the following semester. Students were able to take more electives this way in their areas of interest, which were offered in abundance. Students may take surf P.E., yoga, genetics, Japanese, robotics, etc. There was a focus on project-based learning where the math department focused on thematic units that allowed students to discover concepts while solving a unit problem, physics students built and tested bridges, the robotics class built robots, English students participated in socratic seminars and frequently completed group projects, etc. Student choice and the fostering of individuality were clear in the climate of the school.
Second, the school is about half the size of surrounding high schools and utilizes strategies such as interest-based homeroom periods to further create a smaller school feel. Students really seem to feel connected at school. Both the unique schedule and small school feel are evidence of school restructuring and providing comprehensive support to all students via choice, homeroom support, and time to think and learn.
I cannot think of a practice described in Rethinking High School that BPHS would not still be using. Each practice seemed to have a purpose and be working well for them in furthering student learning. I imagine that as school size changes, requirements from the state changes, student interests change, technology improves, etc, the school will have to remain flexible, incorporating each of these changes into its model.
1. Creating Curricular Paths to Success;
2. Developing Powerful Teaching and Learning;
3. Establishing a Comprehensive Accountability and Assessment System;
4. Providing Comprehensive Support for All Students;
5. Restructuring the School; and
6. Creating New Professional Roles.
First, I think that the internships and career experience they provide students with sets them apart from other schools. Students are able to see direct connections for what they are learning and working on and their futures. They are able to build connections with comminity members, gain work experience, and engage in activities that are meaningful to them. They have a voice in what internships they apply to and hopefully are more engaged as a result. This practice appears to be aligned with creating curricular paths to sucess, restructuring the school and developing powerful teaching and learning.
I also think that the integrated units that BPHS implements are key to their success in helping students experience a more connected and meaningful learning experience at school. Without teachers who collaborate to make their instruction/activities stretch across content areas, studetns would continue to have a fragmented and disjointed educational experience. This practice certainly exemplifies powerful teaching and learning, creates curricular paths to success, and creates new professional roles.
Lastly, I think that their "small school feel" allows them to manage student learning experiences more effectively, making ITU's, internships, and collaboration more feasible. In order for schools who are not small like BPHS to create a small school feel, they must restructure the school and provide comprehensive support for all students so that each individual feels a sense of belonging and purpose.
At my Clinical Practice 1 site, San Dieguito Academy, they used a unique schedule to foster student choice and facilitate project-based learning. The 4x4 schedule that they used allowed students to focus deeply on four subjects at a time for a semster, and then choose four other subjects of focus for the following semester. Students were able to take more electives this way in their areas of interest, which were offered in abundance. Students may take surf P.E., yoga, genetics, Japanese, robotics, etc. There was a focus on project-based learning where the math department focused on thematic units that allowed students to discover concepts while solving a unit problem, physics students built and tested bridges, the robotics class built robots, English students participated in socratic seminars and frequently completed group projects, etc. Student choice and the fostering of individuality were clear in the climate of the school.
Second, the school is about half the size of surrounding high schools and utilizes strategies such as interest-based homeroom periods to further create a smaller school feel. Students really seem to feel connected at school. Both the unique schedule and small school feel are evidence of school restructuring and providing comprehensive support to all students via choice, homeroom support, and time to think and learn.
I cannot think of a practice described in Rethinking High School that BPHS would not still be using. Each practice seemed to have a purpose and be working well for them in furthering student learning. I imagine that as school size changes, requirements from the state changes, student interests change, technology improves, etc, the school will have to remain flexible, incorporating each of these changes into its model.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)